Finance / calculator
Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare editable rent and purchase wealth scenarios with housing costs, mortgage, appreciation, rent growth and investment opportunity assumptions.
Calculator
Calculator
Compare editable rent and buy scenarios.
Compare ending scenario wealth using entered housing costs, growth rates, financing and opportunity returns. The cheaper monthly housing path invests the cost difference.
Your result
Enter details to see the result.
Complete the inputs and calculate to see the main result and its supporting breakdown.
Example
Worked example
Example inputs
- Purchase price
- 200000
- Down payment (%)
- 20
- Mortgage nominal annual rate (%)
- 6
- Mortgage term (whole years)
- 30
- Annual property tax (fixed amount)
- 2400
- Annual insurance (fixed amount)
- 1200
- Annual maintenance (% of current home value)
- 1
- Purchase closing costs (% of price)
- 3
- Sale costs (% of ending home value)
- 6
- Initial monthly rent
- 1500
- Rent annual growth (%)
- 2
- Home annual appreciation (%)
- 2
- Annual investment opportunity return (%)
- 5
- Comparison horizon (whole years)
- 10
Calculation breakdown
Month by month: shared loan payments reduce principal; home/rent grow at entered annual-equivalent monthly factors. Both portfolios grow at entered return; the cheaper housing path invests monthly savings.
- Rent scenario ending investment balance
- 74,929.15
- Buy scenario ending wealth
- 126,490.53
- Rent total housing cash outflow
- 198,895.22
- Buy total housing cash outflow
- 219,213.17
Example result
Buy minus rent modeled ending wealth
51,561.38
Positive favors buy only under these inputs; negative favors rent. This is a scenario comparison, not a recommendation. Both paths invest any monthly housing-cost advantage.
How to interpret the result
Buyer wealth combines home equity after entered sale costs with invested monthly savings. Renter wealth starts with the avoided upfront buying cash and invested cost differences. The output is a scenario comparison and does not recommend either choice.
Annual scenario comparison (same currency)
| Year | Home value | Mortgage balance | Rent investments | Buy investments | Buy ending equity after sale costs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 204,000 | 158,035.18 | 48,300 | 1,056.96 | 33,724.82 |
| 2 | 208,080 | 155,949.18 | 50,715 | 2,496.99 | 39,646.02 |
| 3 | 212,241.6 | 153,734.51 | 53,250.75 | 4,345.87 | 45,772.59 |
| 4 | 216,486.43 | 151,383.25 | 55,913.29 | 6,630.76 | 52,113.99 |
| 5 | 220,816.16 | 148,886.97 | 58,708.95 | 9,380.34 | 58,680.22 |
| 6 | 225,232.48 | 146,236.72 | 61,644.4 | 12,624.85 | 65,481.81 |
| 7 | 229,737.13 | 143,423.02 | 64,726.62 | 16,396.19 | 72,529.89 |
| 8 | 234,331.88 | 140,435.77 | 67,962.95 | 20,727.99 | 79,836.2 |
| 9 | 239,018.51 | 137,264.27 | 71,361.1 | 25,655.71 | 87,413.13 |
| 10 | 243,798.88 | 133,897.16 | 74,929.15 | 31,216.74 | 95,273.79 |
How to use this calculator
- Enter purchase, financing, annual housing expenses and upfront/end-sale cost assumptions.
- Enter rent, its growth, home appreciation, investment opportunity return and horizon.
- Compare modeled ending wealth and annual balances; change assumptions to explore sensitivity.
How it works
Formula
Month by month: shared loan payments reduce principal; home/rent grow at entered annual-equivalent monthly factors. Both portfolios grow at entered return; the cheaper housing path invests monthly savings.
Does a positive buy-minus-rent result mean I should buy?
No. It favors buying only within the supplied mathematical scenario. Personal circumstances, uncertainty, taxes and omitted costs can change the comparison.
What this calculator does
Compare editable housing and investment scenarios over the same period rather than deciding from rent and mortgage payments alone.
Inputs you will need
Required or selected inputs
- Purchase price
- Down payment (%)
- Mortgage nominal annual rate (%)
- Mortgage term (whole years)
- Annual property tax (fixed amount)
- Annual insurance (fixed amount)
- Annual maintenance (% of current home value)
- Purchase closing costs (% of price)
- Sale costs (% of ending home value)
- Initial monthly rent
- Rent annual growth (%)
- Home annual appreciation (%)
- Annual investment opportunity return (%)
- Comparison horizon (whole years)
Assumptions
- Both paths begin with the same available cash: down payment plus buying closing costs. Renting invests that upfront cash. Annual tax/insurance stay fixed; maintenance tracks current home value.
Limitations
- All rates and costs are editable assumptions. Horizon and term are 1–100 years. End sale costs reduce home equity; taxes on returns, moving costs and borrowing for deficits are excluded.
Useful next steps
Check the upfront deposit amount separately with Down Payment Calculator.
References
OpenStax: fixed-rate loan payments and amortization — Reference amortizing-loan payment mathematics. Growth uses the standard compound factor with explicit contribution timing; all rates are user-supplied scenarios.
See how HandyChest handles units, validation, rounding, and testing, or Report a problem with this calculator.
Good to know
Frequently asked questions
How should I read the rent vs buy result?
Buyer wealth combines home equity after entered sale costs with invested monthly savings. Renter wealth starts with the avoided upfront buying cash and invested cost differences. The output is a scenario comparison and does not recommend either choice.
Keep going